Last week Hypothesis saw the largest uptick in interest in our LMS integration since we released the app a little over a year ago. The vast majority of this interest came from individual instructors across the globe grappling with the challenge of moving their courses to remote delivery in the wake of the COVID-19 crisis.
What do we do when we lose the bedrock of face-to-face meetings with our students? While the question is one that those who design online courses and teach online have been answering for many years, due to recent campus closures it’s a challenge that many who have never taught online or even blended courses are now dealing with.
A crisis like this isn’t the time to add complex, unfamiliar practices into people’s lives just when they are struggling with daily logistics. We all know how to write in the margins of a book. Hypothesis enables us to move that familiar practice online so we can do it whenever we can, wherever we are AND also turn it into an opportunity to connect with each other and what we are reading.
While collaborative annotation with Hypothesis isn’t a single all-purpose solution for the many challenges newly online instructors face, it can be a key component in maintaining student engagement with course materials, peers, and instructors as classes move online.
Here are some easy-to-add ideas about how folks — new to online learning and new to collaborative annotation — can make use of Hypothesis to teach and learn remotely.
Webinar: Wednesday 25 March 2020
Hypothesis hosted a webinar on how social reading and collaborative annotation can be leveraged for remote learning. We demonstrated Hypothesis for those new to the tool and elaborated on implementing some of the basic teaching practices outlined in this post. We were also joined by experts in social reading and online learning who shared their own ideas and teaching and learning practices.
Special Guest Presenters
- Amanda Licastro, PhD, Assistant Professor of Digital Rhetoric, Stevenson University
- Kat King, Instructional Technologist, Diablo Valley College and English Instructor, Las Positas College
- Mike Goudzwaard, Associate Director of Learning Innovation in the Dartmouth Center for the Advancement of Learning (DCAL) at Dartmouth College
Meet with the Hypothesis team any day it’s convenient for you to get answers to any of your questions, like: How do I get started with collaborative annotation? How do use collaborative annotation in my teaching and learning? How do I integrate Hypothesis in our learning management system (LMS)? How do I and my organization partner with Hypothesis? Anything else…
1. It’s not about annotation, it’s about community
Yes, we want our students to do the reading. We want them to understand it. We want them to think critically about it. And annotation is a great way to help cultivate those skills and practices. But beyond just being an annotation tool, Hypothesis is also just a great way for students to connect online in a substantive way, to ask each other questions, to share ideas, and to collaborate around their learning.
Video conferencing can literally bring us face to face, which is helpful. But it doesn’t necessarily make it easier to collaborate on specific projects — especially when it may be harder than ever to all be collaborating at the same time. We’re always moving over to something like Google Docs to really get work done, right? Like Google Docs, but for any digital text, collaborative annotation with Hypothesis puts us all on the same page. The reading is really the center of so much teaching and learning and now we can meet there for class — and continue our conversations in the margins if and when we do meet together.
2. Just make your readings annotation-enabled
Instead of simply adding texts to your online courses, add them through the Hypothesis LMS app so that students can take personal notes and have conversations on top of those readings.
Don’t worry about coming up with an annotation activity or assignment. Don’t worry about assessment. Just turn annotation on for your students, give them some basic guidance on how to use the Hypothesis tool, and see how they make use of the digital margins.
By far the most popular praise we get from our student users is that Hypothesis helped them learn from their peers. Of course such peer-to-peer learning, whether formal or informal, is a large part of what face-to-face college experience is all about. Hypothesis creates space for students to connect with each other remotely within the readings for your course, even when they can’t be together in the same space or at the same time.
3. Just annotate yourself
Don’t worry about making students do a new activity or learn a new tool, just annotate the texts yourself for their benefit. This is a very real way to be present in their learning when you can’t physically be in the same place.
I recently noticed a course using Hypothesis that was just a single user creating hundreds of annotations. When I saw the course was in classics, I immediately recognized a valuable use case. Many teachers spend in-class time leading students deliberately through readings. Now this needs to be done online and there’s no better place to do it than in the margins of the text itself.
Some of the most valuable experiences we can pass on as teachers are our own reading practices. Hypothesis enables instructors to guide students through a text remotely, adding glosses and signposts to a difficult reading to help students work their way through.
4. Seminar-style discussion online
As an English teacher, the most important part of my teaching was always the class discussion: a group of students sitting in a circle with their books and pens out, focused on discussing specific passages. This is where I ensured students were comprehending the material. And it’s where we all began the critical work of developing our analyses of text.
From my experience, collaborative annotation is about as close to a seminar-style experience as one can have with a class online. Everyone has the book open, our conversation is grounded in the text and in each other’s comments about it. It’s not the same thing as being face to face in a room together, but it’s a much closer match than a discussion forum or conventional social media where there’s just too much distance between the conversation and the text itself and, quite often, between the comments and commenters themselves. Even if you are meeting “face to face” through video conferencing, annotating the reading together ahead of those synchronous meetings will help make better use of that precious time.
5. Have students annotate your lecture
Of course, not every college course is a seminar. Most are lecture-based with instructors delivering content to a large group of students in a room together. Lecture capture and video conferencing technologies have great features that enable students to attend lectures virtually and engage with each other and instructors, but the underlying content — the basic concepts of a lesson, of a course, and of a discipline — can remain ethereal. Here too, annotation can help.
Post your lecture notes and slide deck as a PDF online and ask students to annotate them with questions. Some video platforms can even generate automatic transcripts of your lectures that you can also post. Like in-class clickers, the notes students make will help you better understand where students are confused and enable you to clarify course concepts. You might even get some feedback on how to improve your own teaching materials!
Hypothesis is a mission-driven organization dedicated to the development and spread of open, standards-based annotation technologies and practices that enable anyone to annotate anywhere, helping humans reason more effectively together through a shared, collaborative discussion layer over all knowledge. Hypothesis is based in San Francisco, CA, USA, with a worldwide team.
Hypothesis has developed its open-source annotation software in collaboration with many partners and funders, including specific projects to augment groups and authentication capabilities with eLife, to enable annotation on EPUBs with NYU, the Readium Foundation, Evident Point, and EPUB.js, and many others. We thank our funders, partners and community for working with us to advance standards-based, interoperable annotation for all.